5 Supreme Court judges, including an Av Bet Din (Chief Judge), whose personality will carry authority and keep order!
The judges are allowed to ask questions in court to assist the proceedings.
They can proceed and decide according to their own personal opinions, basing themselves on the facts provided.
Note: they require all the documentation provided to both sides in litigation, but not the actual Israel Court decision.
1 State Attorney (equivalent of Attorney General) with
2 assistants.
On behalf of the State, to defend the original decision and lead group D.
You have all the documents provided to your witnesses and should build an argument and the scenario for the case to reject Brother Daniel's appeal. Decide what questions you will put to witnesses from the other side during the cross-examination. Build an introductory speech and a summation.
1 Lawyer ( or 2 with different approaches) and
2 assistants.
On behalf of Rufeisen, to present the appeal and lead group C.
You have all the documents provided to your witnesses and should build an argument and the scenario for the appeal, asking that the Ministry of the Interior justify their previous decision and making every effort to prove a miscarriage of justice. Prepare your questions for cross-examination of witnesses from the other side. Build an introductory speech and a summation.
Witnesses for the State Attorney (B), to be called to the stand as experts.
- 1 legal expert who specialises in the interpretation of the Law of Return;
- 1 Government legal official from the Ministry of the Interior, who explains the decision to deny the status of oleh and registration as Jewish to someone who has converted to another religion.
- 1 rabbi and expert on Halakha, who explains orthodox Judaism's attitude to apostates.
Experts and other relevant witnesses to be called for testimony.
- Oswald Rufeisen, (=Brother Daniel).
- 1 legal expert who gives a liberal interpretation of the Law of Return.
- 1 official from the Immigration Ministry who contests the Government's ordinance (see Document no.7) as illegal.
- 1 rabbi (orthodox or otherwise) who believes that no-one ever ceases to be a Jew and brings the relevant arguments as provided.
- 1 person who knew Rufeisen from the Mir ghetto and takes the view that he saved many Jewish lives during the war, and therefore must be honoured as a Jew.
- 1 member / official of the Bnai Brith Anti-Defamation League or any other rights organisation, who takes a universalistic line of argument.
- 1 Catholic priest from the Carmelite order in Israel who has known Brother Daniel (Rufeisen) for many years during which he has been aware of the latter's continued affiliation with his Jewish roots.
1 or 2 clerks to the court who keep the records, documents and assist in the proceedings, including the period when the judges retire to consider their verdict; these roles may be played by madrichim in a small group.